Control before execution

Decision classes

S, D and H state what an AI workflow may do next. The organisation sets the rules. The system applies them. A person holds the authority.

S

Permitted automation

Operate within scope

The request proceeds automatically only when it fits the rules and permissions that the organisation set in advance.

The organisation decides
Which actions run without a person, and inside which limits. The organisation sets these rules in advance.
The system does
It checks that the request fits the rules and the permissions. Then it acts inside the limits and records the result.
The person does
The person does not approve each action by hand. The records stay open for review.
Example
Update the indicators of a district when the source publishes new data.

D

Draft for human review

Prepare, then stop

The system prepares an answer or a recommendation. A person reviews it before any consequential action.

The organisation decides
Which work the system prepares, and who reviews it.
The system does
It assembles an answer or a recommendation. Then it stops and hands the draft to the reviewer. It takes no final action.
The person does
The reviewer reads the draft and decides. Each consequential action is the decision of the person.
Example
Prepare a drought-risk report. An agronomist or a bank analyst reads it and decides.

H

Human approval

Require a person

A designated person with authority approves or declines the action. Execution waits for this decision.

The organisation decides
Which actions need a person with authority, which role approves them, and under which policy.
The system does
It holds the execution and passes the request to the authorised person. It queries no external source on its own for this request.
The person does
The authorised person approves or declines the action. The system records the decision.
Example
Change the terms of a loan. Send a document to an outside organisation.

Rules for every class

What does not change

The same rules hold for S, D and H.

  • The confidence of a model does not widen its permissions.
  • A missing policy or a missing approval is never permission to act.
  • Uncertain or incomplete context moves the request to a stricter class.
  • An unapproved request does not move to a lower class.
  • When the authority check fails or cannot run, the request stops.
  • Only the organisation widens autonomy. It does this through an explicit policy change and an approval.
How a request gets its class